For years, Medicare leads were bought and sold much like any other insurance lead. A beneficiary filled out a form, and their information might be sold to several agencies who all called the same person. Complaints followed, and CMS responded with tighter rules for third-party marketing organizations (TPMOs).
If you buy Medicare leads, here's what changed and what it means for you. This is a plain-language summary, not legal advice, and the rules are updated regularly, so confirm the current requirements with your carriers and compliance team.
Who counts as a TPMO
CMS uses "third-party marketing organization" for organizations and individuals that sell, market or promote Medicare Advantage or Part D plans on behalf of plans, including many agencies, field marketing organizations and lead generators. TPMOs carry specific obligations, including required disclaimers and call recording.
The data-sharing rule
CMS rules now say that a TPMO may not share a beneficiary's personal information with another TPMO for marketing or enrollment purposes unless the beneficiary has given prior express written consent. That consent must make clear who the information will go to.
In practice, this ended the model where one form submission was sold to a long list of buyers. A compliant lead is generated for, and consented to, a specific agency.
Live transfers are different
CMS guidance treats a real-time connection differently from passing a beneficiary's information along for a later callback. When a beneficiary is connected live to an agent during their call, the beneficiary is part of that handoff in the moment. Industry guidance commonly recommends capturing the beneficiary's agreement to the transfer on the recorded line, and outbound calls that are transferred also need valid consent for the original call.
That's one reason inbound calls and live transfers have become central to many compliant Medicare programs.
Other obligations that come with Medicare marketing
- TPMO disclaimer. Required on calls and on websites, telling the beneficiary that the organization doesn't offer every plan available in their area and pointing them to official resources.
- Call recording. TPMOs must record calls with beneficiaries and keep the recordings for the required period.
- Scope of appointment. Agents must document the products to be discussed before a sales meeting, following current timing rules.
- No misleading use of Medicare's name or logo. Ads can't suggest they come from the government.
The TCPA still applies
The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) applies to calls and texts in every industry. Calls made with an autodialer or prerecorded voice, and marketing texts, generally need prior express written consent. Federal and state Do Not Call rules also apply. CMS rules sit on top of these requirements; they don't replace them.
Questions to ask any Medicare lead vendor
- Is each lead generated for my agency only, and is my agency named in the consent?
- Can you provide the consent language, timestamp and page for any lead on request?
- Are inbound calls recorded, and do callers hear the TPMO disclaimer?
- How do you capture consent before a live transfer?
- Which traffic sources do you use, and do you allow sub-publishers?
- How do your ads avoid implying a government program?
- How do you update your process when CMS releases new guidance?
If a vendor can't answer these clearly, look elsewhere. You carry the risk of the leads you call.
Our Medicare lead programs are built around one-to-one consent, recorded calls and current CMS guidance.
We are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. This article is general information, not legal advice.