Home and auto insurance shoppers compare quickly. Many fill out one form and expect several calls, and many buy from the first agent who reaches them with a competitive quote. That makes the choice between exclusive and shared leads one of the biggest decisions a property and casualty agency makes.

How shared leads work

A shared lead is sold to several agencies at once, often three to five. Each pays less than they would for an exclusive lead, and each races to call first.

Shared leads can work for agencies with:

  • Fast, automated dialing
  • A large book of carriers so they can quote almost anyone
  • Agents who are comfortable competing on speed and price

The downsides are real: the shopper is hearing from several agents, contact rates fall quickly after the first few minutes, and the conversation often becomes a pure price comparison.

How exclusive leads work

An exclusive lead is sold to one agency. It costs more per lead, but there's no race. Your agent can call, build rapport and quote properly, and the shopper isn't fielding four other calls at the same time.

Exclusive leads suit agencies that:

  • Win on service and advice, not just price
  • Want to bundle home and auto
  • Have fewer agents and can't afford to lose races

Compare on cost per policy

The price per lead is the wrong number to compare. Use this instead:

Cost per policy = total lead spend ÷ policies written from those leads

Shared leads usually win on cost per lead. Exclusive leads often win, or close the gap, on cost per policy because more of them are reached and quoted. The only way to know for your agency is to test both and track each source to written policies.

What else affects results

Speed to contact

Whatever you buy, call fast. Shoppers are most reachable in the first minutes after they request a quote. See our guide to speed to contact for insurance quotes.

Screening

Ask for the filters that matter to your carriers: homeowners only, currently insured, no recent incidents, specific ZIP codes, renewal month. Tighter filters cost more but waste less agent time.

Bundling

Agencies that quote home and auto together often see better retention. If bundling is your strategy, filter auto leads for homeowners and home leads for drivers.

Every lead should come with consent naming your agency, a timestamp and a source page. Avoid vendors whose ads promise guaranteed savings or specific rates.

Questions to ask any P&C lead vendor

  1. Is each lead sold to one agency, or several? How many?
  2. Where does traffic come from, and do you use publishers?
  3. What screening is included, and what can I add?
  4. Can you post to EZLynx, AgencyZoom or my CRM?
  5. What's your return policy for invalid leads?
  6. Can I see a sample consent record?

A sensible way to start

Run a one-month test with a modest daily cap, in the ZIP codes where your carriers are most competitive. Track contact rate, quote rate and policies written by source. Scale what produces the lowest cost per policy, not the cheapest leads.

See our home insurance and auto insurance programs.

This article is general information for licensed agents.